God’s Answer to “Free Palestine”: Ezekiel 36

The news is full of those screaming to “Free Palestine”, as well as those saying, “From the River to the Sea”, both having the same desired result- the destruction of Israel and the genocide of Jews.

And don’t think this is just about Jews in Israel- it is about Judaism, itself! Israel is just the first step.

But God has already told us what the result will be to these antisemitic terrosists.

If you prefer to watch a video, click on this link: Watch the video.

In Ezekiel 36, God is speaking to the children of Israel who have been disbursed and defeated by their enemies, all because of the way they have violated Torah and defamed God’s name, both in Israel and even in the lands to which they were disbursed.

But God says that because those enemies of Israel have boasted about the troubles the people of God have suffered, and stated how they will take over the land now deserted (pretty much the “river to the sea” thing), God will punish them and return and bless the children of Israel.

In other words, as ignorant Americans and others cry to “Free Palestine!” (which doesn’t even exist, so how can you free something that doesn’t exist?), God has already told them that he will free his people to take over and remain forever in the land he promised to give us.

There was never really any established “state” of Palestine, to begin with!

After the Jewish revolts against Rome (especially the Bar Kokhba Revolt, AD 132–135), the Roman Emperor Hadrian deliberately renamed the province of Judea to Syria Palaestina, adding insult to injury by renaming the land after the ancient enemies of the Jewish people, the Philistines. This was later anglisized to Palestine, which wasn’t a state but a territory first controlled by the Ottoman Empire until England took it over.

It continued to be called Palestine but it was never established as a state with any constitution or recognized official documentation. The closest thing that came to any kind of official constitution was created in 2003 by the PLA, a terrorist organization which also created this whole “Palestinian people” propaganda program; they call it the “Palestinian Basic Law” which creates their fantasized state of Palestine with their own governing authority, even claiming Jerusalem as their capital.

While there are so many ignorant and genocidal puppets calling for the “River to the Sea”, which would be the end of Israel and Judaism, God has told them what will happen- he will establish his people and destroy their enemies. That which the PLA and all those terrorist organizations want to do will come back down on their own heads.

We can see that happening even today. Sadly, it will get worse before it gets better, but no matter how rough the ride, what matters is where you end up, and the final destination will be Israel under God’s protection, and the enemies of Israel, who- for the record- are the enemies of God (not a place I would want to be) will be totally destroyed.

My advice to the “Free Palestine” idiots is this: be careful what you ask for because what you want to happen to us is going to happen to you!

Thank you for being here and please remember to comment and share these messages with everyone you know, even non-believers. Hey, after all, you never know how fertile the soil is until you plant a seed in it.

That’s it for this week, so l’hitraot and (an early) Shabbat Shalom!

Why Israel is Still Being Attacked.

Israel has been under attack long before it was an established state in 1948.

In fact, the attack on Israel is just a part of the real attack, which has been on God’s chosen people since he decided to choose us as his own.

If you prefer to watch a video, click on this link: Watch the video.

I recently posted on my Facebook page that the reason Israel is still under attack is because we haven’t learned from Joshua’s failure to do what God told him to do, which was to utterly destroy the sinful peoples of the land to which God was giving to the Tribes of Israel.

When God brought us out of Egypt and to Cana’an, the enemies of God living there had polluted the land with their sinful ways, which is why God told us to totally destroy them. God would give the land to us so that we could restore it to its full fruitfulness and cleanse it of sin.

But Joshua and the people failed to do as God commanded them, showing distrust (as they had been doing since being freed from Egypt) and not having the self-reliance to do as God said. Hence, those peoples have remained in the land, and have grown to such a large number that today they outnumber us by a ratio of 60-70 Arabs per single Jew.

Yet, despite the many times they have tried to destroy us, God has saved us.

The problem today is that Israel is still going against what God said to do, which is to totally destroy their enemies, who are the enemies of God. As God’s rod of punishment, we have been as limp and useless as a wet noodle.

Why is that? It is because we are trying to please the world instead of doing as God said we should!

Israel needs to tell the UN (which should be renamed the UNAI- United Nations Against Israel) that the idea of a two-nation peace is ridiculous because the enemies of Israel do not want peace, they want Israel destroyed, and that from this moment on Hamas, ISIS, Hezbollah, and every other terrorist anti-Jewish organization throughout the Middle East and the world is on the Israeli Hit List.

And anyone who is in the way will be an unfortunate casualty of war; sorry, but you have until we get there to get the heck outta Dodge, otherwise your blood is on your own head.

Now THAT is what will place God completely on our side, and no one can stand against God when he is using his chosen people as his rod of punishment. We need to be separate from the world, which is where we should have been centuries ago.

The world is a sinful place, ruled by Satan, and the more Israel tries to appease the world, the weaker our relationship with God will become.

And if that doesn’t scare the heck out of the Knesset, nothing will.

Thank you for being here and please remember to comment and share these messages with everyone you know, even non-believers. Hey, after all, you never know how fertile the soil is until you plant a seed in it.

That’s it for today, so l’hitraot and Baruch HaShem!

Whom Do You Obey?

I have always said that God has no religion; religion was created by men in order to have power over other men.

This has been the reason that so many people who think they are worshipping God correctly are actually on the wrong path.

If you prefer to watch a video, click on this link: Watch the video.

Judaism is based on the Torah, which are the first five books of the Bible and are, in fact, the only place in the entire Bible where God, himself, tells us how to worship him and how to treat each other.

Christianity grew from a Jewish movement that accepted Yeshua (Jesus) as the Messiah God promised to send, and after Yeshua’s crucifixion and resurrection, allowed Gentiles into that movement. These neophyte Gentile believers were learning about the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, as well as learning about the Torah.

The confusion began with Shaul (Paul) teaching the many Gentile messianic congregations he formed (there was no “church” in the First Century) about obeying the Torah out of a faithful trust in God, and not in order to earn salvation. His problems were exclusively with the believing Jews who were forcing the Gentiles to undergo B’rit Milah (circumcision) in order to be saved.

The Elders in Jerusalem, led by Yacov (James) helped in this by writing a letter that identified 4 requirements- INITIAL requirements, not the only requirements- for these Gentile believers to obey, stating that they would eventually learn the Torah by attending Shabbat services (Acts 15).

These Gentile believers had another problem, besides the believing Jews “legalizing” them, and that was Rome. You see, the Jews had been rebelling against Roman rule, and there were three major rebellions, the third and final one being around 170 CE, which resulted in the death of thousands of Jews and most of the remaining Jews being disbursed throughout the Diaspora. The Romans added insult to injury by retitling Judea to Syria Palaestina, which in English is Palestine.

The problems and confusion that has caused is for another discussion.

So, as the Jewish movement became more and more infiltrated with Gentiles (sorry, but that is the best word I can use) and as the Jewish leaders die, no more Jews were coming in because the Gentile leaders were transforming this Jewish movement into a new religion, rejecting the Torah and forming their own holidays and rituals. By the end of the Second Century, they had a polytheistic religion by creating the idea of the Trinity, which was an absolute turn-off to the Jews, even those who were willing to hear about this guy Yeshua, now rebranded as Jesus, a Christian savior.

What started out as a Jewish movement accepting Yeshua as the Messiah and even allowing Gentiles to join to receive salvation, was mutated into a new religion called Christianity which was against Judaism and rejected the Torah.

Within Judaism there are 6 sects: Chasidic/Ultra-Orthodox, Orthodox (modern-day Pharisees), Conservative, Reform, Reconstructionist, and Messianic (although mainstream Jews do not accept Messianic as Jewish). And we can see that there are different ways that Jews interpret how to obey the Torah, but we are all basing our worship of God on how he said to do it.

Now, if you ask Google how many different Christian religions there are, this is the answer you will get:

There are an estimated 45,000 to over 49,000 Christian denominations globally. This massive number exists because of differing historical interpretations, cultural shifts, and the rapid growth of independent, localized churches.

So, we have to ask ourselves this question: how can there be so many different ways to worship God with so many different tenets and credos and holidays if they are all basing their worship on the Bible?

And the answer is obvious: they are not basing it on what God said but on what some human being said.

Christianity is not based on the Torah, although it does recognize the 10 Commandments and takes some things from the Torah.

The truth is that Christianity, for the most part, is a man-made religion that is based on an anti-Torah foundation, misusing and misinterpreting letters some Pharisee wrote to Gentile congregations having interpersonal power struggles and issues of faith. It is not based on how God said to live and worship him, but on what people have said how they want you to worship God.

That brings us back to the question I asked in the title of today’s message: Whom do you obey?

If you want to obey God, then you really need to do what God said to do, and if you have been taught differently, then how can you be obeying God? You can’t! You have to be obeying some man-made religion that has rejected what God said to do.

If you are thinking to yourself, “How can I be wrong if there are millions of Christians doing (pretty much) what I do?”, think about this:

When I meet God at Judgement Day, as we all will have to, I can say, “I tried my best to live as you said I should.”

But if you follow a religion that is not Torah based, the best you can say is, “I did what they told me I should do.”

Now, I can’t speak for the Big Guy upstairs, but I believe his answer to you would be something like this:
“I understand, my child, that you did what they told you to do, but it is what I say that counts!”

Do you really want to hear that when where you will spend eternity is being decided?

Oh, by the way, if you think Yeshua will get you out of that situation, don’t count on it, because he lived and taught the Torah and he never said anyone should ignore his father’s rules. In fact, he already has warned you about this in Matthew 7:21-23:

Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord!’ will enter the Kingdom of Heaven, only those who do what my Father in heaven wants.

Chew on that the next time your religion tells you the Torah is just for Jews.

Thank you for being here and please remember to comment and share these messages with everyone you know, even non-believers. Hey, after all, you never know how fertile the soil is until you plant a seed in it.

That’s it for this week, so l’hitraot and let me wish you Chag Sameach Shavuot!

Why Does God Test Us If He Already Knows Our Mind?

I have often wondered about this: if God knows our minds and hearts, why bother to test us?

I mean, he already knows what we will do, so what’s the point?

If you prefer to watch a video, click on this link: Watch the video.

After thinking it over, I came to the realization that God doesn’t test us so he will see what we do, he test us so that WE will see what we do.

Let’s look at Abraham: when Abraham and Sarah went to Egypt to escape the famine (Genesis 12), Abraham asked Sarah to say she was his sister because she was quite a hottie and he was afraid he would be killed so another man could take her as his own wife (it ended up being the Pharaoh).

I don’t get it: it was wrong to take a man’s wife away from him,
but if you killed him first then it was OK. SMH!

I believe this showed Abraham’s faith was not yet ready for him to be given a son, since he didn’t trust in God to protect him. And this wasn’t the only time: he did the same thing later when he was in the land that belonged to Abimelech (Genesis 20). Fortunately, when she was with Pharaoh and Abimelech, God intervened to protect her from being misused; but, still and all, it showed Abraham’s faith wasn’t strong enough yet for his greatest test.

God knows that the one thing human beings rarely understand is their own heart. The best way for us to know what we will do in any given situation is to be in that situation: we may say we would do what is right when asked, but we really don’t know what we will actually do until we are in the midst of the trouble.

I hate to admit it, but I believe that if I lived in Yeshua’s time, it is very likely that I would be in the crowd asking for Barabbas.

It is always easy to know what we should do, but until we are facing that situation, no one can be sure how they will react.

That is why God tests us- it isn’t because he doesn’t know what we will do, it is to show us what we will do.

In war, no one can tell what they will do until the bullets start to fly, and even in everyday life, you don’t really know what you will do until you have to do something.

When you see a homeless person on the street, do you pass them by or offer to buy them something to eat?

When you have old clothes still in pretty good shape, do you toss them in the garbage or clean them and take them to a Goodwill?

These are tests- remember what Yeshua said about feeding him when he was hungry and clothing him when he had no clothes (Matthew 25)?

We are always tested, sometimes by God and other times by people, and (as I said) no one can really know what they will do until the test is before them. My suggestion is that we read the Bible constantly so that when there is a situation before us, we can recognize the test and by knowing what God wants from us, we will be able to pass it.

When we are in school we generally know when a test is coming, so we study for it in order to do well. In life, the best way to study is to know the Bible- the entire Bible- because it is a rare thing to know when life will test us; life is full of pop quizzes and surprise tests, and the best way to prepare for them is to know what is right in God’s eyes.

So, I’d say it is a good idea to review your past to see when you have already been tested; I believe we are tested daily but so few of us realize it.

I don’t know about you, but I want to have a passing grade when God reviews me at Judgement Day. And yes, Yeshua provides the “curve” to ensure I pass, but there are different levels when we will be on the new earth, and I want to make the Honor Roll.

Thank you for being here and please remember to share these messages with everyone you know, even non-believers. Hey, after all, you never know how fertile the soil is until you plant a seed in it.

That’s it for today, so l’hitraot and Baruch HaShem!

Is “Church Art” Acceptable Under the 2nd Commandment?

I have seen many posts where there is an image of God or Yeshua and pointed out that this is not really allowed. Sometimes I get the response that it is acceptable because it is “church art”.

So, is church art different from images?

If you prefer to watch a video, click on this link: Watch the video.

I think the best way to settle this is to look at the 2nd Commandment and see what God says (CJB):

  You are not to make for yourselves a carved image or any kind of representation of anything in heaven above, on the earth beneath or in the water below the shoreline.

I don’t know about you, but this seems pretty clear to me.

Yet even within Judaism, which does not make any three-dimensional images (i.e., statues or busts), two-dimensional images of biblical scenes, animals, and biblical persons (such as Moses) have been seen in synagogues as far back as the 3rd century AD.

The 2nd Commandment goes a little further saying that we should not bow down to or pray to these images, which is never done in Judaism, but I regret to say in most any Catholic Church I have ever been in- and I’ve been in a lot of them having traveled to many countries and throughout the USA- I see three-dimensional images and people bowing down and praying to them.

I have been told that they aren’t really “praying” to them but simply asking them to intercede with Jesus to intercede with God. Funny… the Catholic Church pretty much says Jesus is God, so how do you intercede with yourself? And Jesus said that the only way to the father is through him (John 14:6), so again- why go to anyone else?

And isn’t praying asking for something? And when you ask for something isn’t that praying?

I have no definitive answer other than the safest thing to do is not make any images of anything, ever. That way there can’t be confusion, but on the other hand, people learn from three different types of input: visual (65%), aural (30%) and tactile (5%). Since the vast majority of people learn through visual stimulation then to help get the word out, it seems to make sense that some sort of artwork would be helpful.

(My personal opinion is that 100% of the people learn best by doing)

I doubt that we will never be without some form of artwork relating to religion so maybe we can just settle with church art should be restricted to biblical scenes that allow for representation of animals, background, and people who are involved in an activity spoken about in the Bible, but absolutely no images of any kind of God or Messiah.

Images showing what the idols of pagan religions looked like as part of a learning experience would be okay, as long as they are just that- part of a lesson to introduce what those idols looked like to teach us how to recognize them.

What do you think? I’d like to know your opinion on this.

That’s it for this week. Thank you for being here and please comment and share these messages with everyone you know, even non-believers. Hey, after all, you never know how fertile the soil is until you plant a seed in it.

That’s it for this week, so l’hitraot and (an early) Shabbat Salom!

Which Covenants Are Conditional and Which Are Not

How about a nice, easy lesson today? Let’s talk covenants.

If you prefer to watch a video, click on this link: Watch the video.

Before we talk about covenants, let’s make sure we are all on the same page as to what a covenant is: it is an agreement between two or more parties, and it can be conditional or unconditional.

Conditional covenants are those where each party promises to perform some act in order to make the covenant valid, and if either party violates their side of the agreement, then the covenant is rendered null and void.

Unconditional covenants are those where one side of the agreement promises to perform some act and the other side is not required to do anything.

Simple, right?

Okay, so the main 5 covenants we know from the Bible are these:

  1. Noahdic Covenant– God promises unconditionally not to destroy life by a flood anymore, and the rainbow is the sign of that covenant.
  2. Abrahamic Covenant– God promises Abraham that he will make him into a nation and give him the land of the Canaanites. He also promises that those who curse Abraham will be cursed, and those who bless him will be blessed. The sign of this covenant is that all the males of Abraham’s family and slaves must be circumcised.
  3. The Mosaic Covenant- God promises to make us into a holy nation if we obey the laws he gives us. The sign of this covenant is the Shabbat (Sabbath).
  4. The Davidic Covenant– God promises King David that so long as his children obey God’s commandments (in the Torah) then he will always have a descendant sitting on the throne. Most important about this is that he also promises to make David’s house a perpetual house, which is understood to be the promise that the Messiah will be a descendant of David.
  5. The New Covenant– Despite what you may think, this is not in the New Covenant writings, but in Jeremiah 31:31. God promises to write his Torah on our hearts and forgive our sins so that no longer will anyone have to say “Know Adonai” because we will all know him.

So, now that we have the covenants down, let’s identify which ones are conditional and which aren’t.

There is really only one that is unconditional, the Noahdic Covenant. God doesn’t require anything from us in that covenant.

The other four are all conditional: for Abraham we need to be a circumcised male (although obviously females won’t have to undergo that), for the Mosaic Covenant we need to obey the Torah, and the Davidic Covenant is conditional upon David’s descendants obeying the Torah.

Although the New Covenant doesn’t specify any requirement, I have to believe that if someone has not turned their heart towards God they probably won’t be allowed into that covenant.

You may be thinking why God, who has always kept his side of the bargain even though we have often (actually, always) broken our side of his covenants, has still done what he said he would do regarding the conditional covenants.

I think the answer is this: God loves us so much that he is willing to allow us to screw up over and over, but he will not take advantage of his legal right to break his side of the covenant.

I believe this is pretty obvious when we see how many times God has allowed his people to violate his covenants yet was willing to forgive us when we did T’shuvah (turning from sin) in order that the covenant would remain in force.

Ezekiel 18:23 says it best: God doesn’t want to see anyone die (meaning an eternal death), which is why he maintains his side of broken covenants, just waiting for us to re-establish our side.

And when we fail to get around to replacing our heads on our shoulders from where we had them (I won’t say where, but the sun doesn’t shine there), God eventually runs out of patience and decides to give us some motivation, such as a plague, sending the sword against us, famine, etc. He still keeps his side, despite our violation, and instead of just leaving us be he tries to get us back on track.

However, for those who constantly and happily violate the covenants, God will allow them to go their own way, which I believe is very painful to him. But because he loves us so much, he is willing to allow us to kill ourselves, even when he doesn’t want that to happen.

One more thing about covenants- they are in force until one side breaks them or whatever time period they may have attached to them runs out. As for God’s Torah, he gives us a term limit- throughout all your generations.

That means as long as we are alive, those laws are valid and required to be in the covenant with God. Christianity has taught that you can violate the Mosaic Covenant without any repercussions, but that is a false teaching, unless you can show that you have no more generations.

Yeshua lived in accordance with all God’s covenants, including the Torah, which is why he was resurrected- like it or not, the Torah IS the path to salvation because it is God’s “User Manual for Righteousness”, and obedience to the Torah will result in salvation; Yeshua proved that by being resurrected.

The problem is that humans cannot do that, which is why God sent the Messiah, to cover our tuchas when we screw up.

Everyone is under the Noahdic Covenant, and can be under every other covenant if they choose to be obedient and meet the requirements for our side of the agreement. To be saved you do not have to be circumcised because being a member of the Abrahamic Covenant is not a requirement for salvation, but if you want to be saved you need to recognize that believing in Yeshua is NOT a part of any of the covenants, and salvation cannot be earned so it is not a covenental issue, either. Believing in Yeshua is required to receive forgiveness by means of the sacrificial blood he shed, replacing the need to bring an animal to the temple.

Salvation is eternal life, and it is a side-effect of the New Covenant, but (as I said earlier) I truly believe that anyone who rejects obedience to God’s Mosaic Covenant will not be allowed to participate in the New Covenant.

It just doesn’t make sense that God will allow those who purposefully reject his Torah to be forgiven, despite what your Christian religion may tell you.

Here is something to consider: at the end of time we will all face God, and some will say, “I tried to be obedient to your covenants” and others will say, “I did what my man-made religion told me was okay to do.”

So nu?… which of those people do you think God will accept into his presence?

Thank you for being here and please remember to comment and share these messages, even with non-believers. Hey, after all, you never know how fertile the soil is until you plant a seed in it.

That’s it for today, so l’hitraot and Baruch HaShem!

Will the New Covenant Replace Free Will?

For many years I have been saying that one of the greatest gifts God has given us is Free Will, the right to choose how we live our lives.

Recently, though, I have begun to think that when the prophecies of the End Days are fulfilled, the way God will do away with sin is to take away Free Will.

If you prefer to watch a video, click on this link: Watch the video.

In the books of the Prophets (Nevi’im) we read how we will all be brought back to the Land and once there we will live in peace. The New Covenant (Jeremiah 31:31) says that God will write his Torah (meaning teachings, i.e., how to worship him and how to treat each other) on our hearts, and in Ezekiel 36:26 God says:

I will give you a new heart and put a new spirit in you; I will remove from you your heart of stone and give you a heart of flesh.

Jewish tradition has always considered the heart the center of intellect, will, and conscience. It is more than just the emotional center; it is also the thinking part of our consciousness. It is the inner, essential self that directs moral choices, where good and evil impulses battle, and where Torah is internalized.

The prophecies of the afterlife, once the bowls of wrath are emptied, the shofars sounded, etc., and Yeshua has defeated the Enemy once and for all, those of us who have accepted Yeshua, lived our lives in accordance with the way Yeshua lived his life, and tried our best (because no one can be perfect) to obey God, we will be the remnant of humanity that gets to live in God’s presence forever.

Shaul (Paul) tells us in 1 Corinthians 15 that when we are resurrected we will be resurrected with a spiritual body, and Yeshua tells us that there is a difference between the earthly and the spiritual, so there is definitely something that will be significantly different when we are resurrected to eternal life.

And, since all the prophecies talk of joy, no more tears, no more suffering- all which are the result of sin- then it seems to me, now, that the only way we sinful creatures can be sinless will be to have the opportunity to be sinful taken away from us.

And the only way that can be done is to resurrect us without free will, so that we cannot choose to sin.

For many years I have said free will is a gift that God gave us so we could choose to love him and not be automatons, doing what we do because we didn’t have any choice, and I believe that is still true. However, now I believe it is true only while we are in this plane of existence.

When we are resurrected, it will be without free will because God will give us new heart, one with his Torah written on it so there won’t be an option to reject his Torah, any more than we have an option to reject using our heart.

And you know what? That is okay by me because what is important is that in this life we have proven our desire to live according to God’s instructions even though we are not able to do so.

What I am saying is that even though in this existence the idea that we do not have free will seems to de-humanize us, if we show God that while we have free will to disobey we don’t want to, in the afterlife he will reward us with eternal joy by taking away that potential to screw things up by sinning, because humans cannot live without sinning.

Sin is born into us in this existence not as a punishment, but as a means to show God that we are trying our best to live in accordance with his instructions (in the Torah), even though it goes against our basic nature. It is the struggle to be sinless that counts, not how sinless we are.

I now believe that the effort to be sinless is what counts with God, and having Yeshua to provide us the means to be forgiven of our sins is what keeps us in line for salvation.

In this life we must accept that Yeshua is the Messiah God promised to send, that his sacrifice provides the means for us to be forgiven of sin, and that so long as we try to live our lives the same way that Yeshua lived his, which was to be Torah observant (obeying God and not men; men created religion to have power over other men), then our reward will be salvation, eternal life in God’s presence, with a new heart that is pure and sinless.

The greatest gift God has given us in this earthly life is free will, allowing us to choose what we will do, and the greatest gift God will give us in the afterlife is the lack of free will, preventing us from hurting ourselves by not having the ability to sin.

Thank you for being here and please remember to share these messages with everyone you know, even non-believers. Hey, after all, you never know how fertile the soil is until you plant a seed in it.

That’s it for this week, so l’hitraot and (an early) Shabbat Shalom!

More Arguments Why the Gospel of John is a False Gospel

I have often stated that I believe the Gospel of John is a false gospel, and by that I mean it is not written by the real apostle John, and even more than that, I do not believe it was even written by a Jewish person.

Warning: this one will be longer than most of my messages.

If you prefer to watch a video, click on this link: Watch the video.

I think we first have to remember that what started out as a movement within the Jewish people, one where Yeshua was being recognized as anything from a prophet to the Messiah, had originally been (except for a very few exceptions) only within the Jewish population . It wasn’t until about 3-4 years after his resurrection that Shaul (Paul) changed his mind about Yeshua and began to open the path to salvation through Yeshua (now recognized as the Messiah) to the Gentile population throughout the Middle East and Asia. This was a paradigm shift in lifestyle for those Gentiles, and Shaul was bringing them into Torah observance at a pace they could handle.

The problem was that the Jews were rebelling against Roman rule and, as such, the Gentile believers started to get worried that their conversion would target them along with the Jews, so that by the end of the First Century, when most of the original Jewish leaders had been martyred or dead and the majority of Jews who would believe in Yeshua had come and gone, the movement that was Jewish mutated into a new religion called Christianity, which by the middle of the Second Century (after the Jewish rebellion had been put down, once and for all around 132 AD), this new religion was targeted by Rome, anyway, because the one thing Rome hated more than rebellion was a religion other than their own in one of their territories.

Okay, so now we have the historical background to support why this Jewish movement was moving away from Judaism by the time John wrote his gospel.

According to scholars, John was exiled to Patmos around 93 AD, spent anywhere from 18 months to 3 years there, then was released and eventually returned to Ephesus, He died there around 100 AD at the approximate age of 92. He wrote about his vision of the Apocalypse while on Patmos, but his gospel wasn’t written until after he returned to Ephesus.

According to scholars, the three narrative gospels were each written sometime within 40 years or so of Yeshua’s death and resurrection around 30 AD: Mark wrote his gospel around 70 AD, Matthew and Luke were written around 80-85 AD.

Now what is funny here is that when you look up when Matthew was supposed to have died, it is sometime between 68-70 AD, some 10-15 years before he was supposed to have written his gospel! And if the other gospels were written within 40 years or so of the resurrection, why did John wait over 60 years?

I contend that no one really knows when the gospels were written, they only have guesses. And we know that many times scribes would write letters from notes made by someone, signing that person’s name. This is suspected to have been done with a number of Shaul’s (Paul) letters.

(You can check that out in the teaching series I have written regarding the Epistles- here is a link to that series of teachings: the Epistles.)

So, with these questionable issues about any and all of the gospels, let me go into some of the reasons I feel that John is not a valid gospel, at all, and written by a Gentile using the name of John.

One reason is that he doesn’t write about the Torah or the Jews correctly. What I mean is that a Jew would never call the people “the Jews”, which John does nearly 60 times throughout this gospel; to a Jew, the other Jews are “the people”. And a Jew would never, ever refer to the Torah as “their Torah”, which John does in his gospel.

Another reason I doubt the validity of John is because it fails the test of Hermeneutics, which is the exegesis tool that says every part of the Bible should not contradict any other part of the Bible, since it was all (allegedly) inspired by God, who never changes.

How John fails this test is, for one, where he refers to the Samaritan woman at the well (John 4). The other three gospels are clear that Yeshua says he has come only for the children of Israel (Matthew 15:24) and explicitly says to his disciples not to tell anyone he is the Messiah (Matthew 16:20, Mark 8:30, and Luke 9:21), yet here in John he not only tells this Samaritan woman he is the Messiah (failing to match what the other gospels said), but he stays in her town and teaches there for 2 days (again, totally against what Yeshua says in the other gospels)!

And when it comes to the idea of the Trinity (which arguments for or against will not be part of this discussion), almost every justification for saying Yeshua is also God comes only from John’s gospel. Nowhere in any of the other Gospels does Yeshua even hint that he is God. And I also will go as far as to say the miracle of making wine from water (John 2) is designed specifically to show that Mary has some level of authority over Yeshua!

Think about it: the Roman Catholic Church (which was the only church until about 1054) has constantly had people pray to Mary to intervene with Jesus. This miracle indicates that she has that power, since he first said he didn’t want to do anything, but she went ahead and had him do it, anyway. And another thing: every miracle that Yeshua performed in the other three gospels had to do with healing of one sort or another- but in John he makes wine from water for a party! Why? I believe it is only to indicate the authority that Mary has over Yeshua and within the Catholic Church.

Another thing about John is that the writing is stylistically not “Jewish”. Even as confusing as Shaul’s letters are, John is full of double-talk and overly spiritualized metaphor that makes it almost impossible to tell when Yeshua is talking literally or figuratively.

I am Jewish and understand Jewish logic, which is that we Jews will tell you everything something is not before we tell you what it is, but John is written so confusingly that you don’t know what is real and what is not:
If you know me you know him, but you don’t know him so you can’t know me, and that is why you don’t know me because you don’t know him, yadda-yadda-yadda…

One last thing, and I appreciate anyone who has stayed with me this long: by the end of the First Century, the one thing that the Jews and (now called) Christians had in common was this: neither side wanted any more Jews joining this movement. Even Shaul recognized this shift by stating that the Jews will no longer accept Yeshua until the time of the Gentiles is over (Romans 11:25).

By the time John was supposed to have been written, already Christianity was separating itself from its Jewish beginnings by changing the Shabbat to Sunday (Ignatius of Antioch proclaimed that around 98 AD) and by the time of Tertullian’s influential writings (which, for the record, is where the term “trinity” originated) in the middle of the Second Century, Christianity had changed from a Jewish movement inviting Gentiles to a totally new Gentile religion that rejected the Jews and “their” Torah.

John’s gospel is written in a way that would turn-off any self-respecting Jew from even wanting to hear anything more about Yeshua. That is how I was raised, as many Jews have been for millennia, being taught that Jesus was a Jew but turned against Judaism and created Christianity.

Of course, that is untrue- Yeshua was, and still is, Jewish but he did not create Christianity! Men did, and they did so by misusing the letters Shaul wrote and doing everything they could to keep Jews from wanting to know anything about this new godhead of theirs called Jesus Christ.

And that is why I believe, for the reasons stated above, this so-called gospel was written by a Gentile leader of the new religion called Christianity designed specifically to keep Jews away and to further separate this new religion from its Jewish roots.

Thank you for staying through this, and I am sure it is very uncomfortable for many, especially Gentiles, to hear what I am saying. I am not telling anyone to change what they believe, only what I believe and why- you make up your own minds.

That’s it for today so L’hitraot and Baruch HaShem!

Anti-Christianity is Not Anti-Christian

Being anti-something isn’t always a bad thing, depending on why anyone is against a certain thing. If a person is hateful and bigoted, that is usually based in ignorance and upbringing, whereas if someone is against something for moral or religious reasons, that doesn’t necessitate hatefulness.

If you prefer to watch a video, click on this link: Watch the video.

This message came to me after a discussion with a friend last night, when he told me that I was Anti-Christian. I replied (as my defense) that I was Anti-Christian teaching, but not Anti-Christian.

I am grateful to him for telling me, straight out, that if I am Anti-Christian teaching then I am Anti-Christian. And, in response to that, I had to say he was right.

But I am not Anti-Christian, I am Anti-Christianity. That is the difference between being a bigot and just not agreeing with a religious belief system.

From my lifetime of knowing people who are Anti-Semitic (when you’re Jewish you get to meet a lot of people like that) I have found that the basis for their hatred is not religious, whatsoever. They are not against us worshipping God, or for being devoted to the Torah, although I have been accused of being a Christ-killer, but even that is not enough to generate the level of hatred and violence against us.

The main reason, from my experience, for people being Anti-Semitic is economic. We have been accused of controlling the media and the finances of the world. We even have been accused of being the children of Satan (John 8:44).

The fact that we have been very successful in business and finance has not helped dispel that lie.

But my being Anti-Christianity is not based on economics, social positioning, or anything other than the teachings that Christianity has been proliferating for nearly two millennia. I do not hate any Christians, but I do hate the things they have been taught.

Some examples of those teachings being replacing God the father with Yeshua the Messiah, bowing and praying to statues, telling people that they can ignore the Torah because Yeshua did away with it (which makes the son of God a traitor to his father misleading people away from proper worship), and (this is a biggie!) teaching that Jews are no longer God’s chosen people because God has rejected the Jews as a result of us rejecting his son.

Having a love and respect for God and Yeshua, those teachings are, to me, as annoying as someone insulting my wife in front of me.

So, yes, I am an Anti-Christianity person but I am not against Christians. You might call this one of those times where we hate the sin but love the sinner.

And despite being told, more times than I care to count, that I do not know the Bible or understand the Epistles or that I can’t really be saved because I still do all that “Jewish” stuff, I know that if I continue to try to live as best as I can in accordance with the way God said to live and worship him (which is only found in the Torah), faithfully trusting that Yeshua is the Messiah and through his sacrifice I am able to find forgiveness of sin (which is, ultimately, what being saved means), then I am absolutely positive that I am on the right path to salvation.

And despite not liking Christianity, I still can love Christians.

This ministry is devoted to teaching the truth, as I believe it to be, about who God is, who the Messiah is, what he taught, and how best to serve God in the way we worship him and treat each other. I try to make sure I have biblical justification for every and anything I teach

I have many who disagree with me, on both the Christian and Jewish side, but I never tell anyone what they should believe, only what I believe and why I believe it.

I will argue (always nicely and with respect) with anyone who disagrees, and if we cannot come to an agreement, then so be it- we can each shake the dust from our sandals and go somewhere else. The fact remains that nothing I say, or you say, or anyone says is going to count at all when we come before the Lord God, Almighty at Judgement Day because all that will count with God is what he says.

And when we come before him, as we all shall do, at least I can say that I tried to do what God said to do and not what some men who created their own religion said to do.

Frankly, I think that will go over a lot better with God than someone who says they did what their religion said to do.

Thank you for being here and please remember to share these messages with everyone you know, even non-believers. Hey, after all, you never know how fertile the soil is until you plant a seed in it.

That’s it for this week so L’hitraot, and (an early) Shabbat Shalom!

Legalism Existed Way Before Shaul

When reading the letters that Shaul (Paul) wrote, we often come to the problem he faced with believing Jews telling the neophyte believing Gentiles they must perform every Jewish ritual in order to be saved. This is known as “Legalism”, and most people think it started at that time.

But they are wrong.

If you prefer to watch a video, click on this link: Watch the video.

Let’s first make sure we are all on the same page when it comes to understanding what legalism really is: it is a performance-based salvation, meaning that you earn salvation by doing what the Torah says you should do. Faith is secondary to performance, and often doesn’t even come into the picture.

Now, let’s also realize something that traditional Christianity has taught which is wrong: you CAN be saved if you completely and always obey the Torah. How can I say that? Easily- someone proved it to be true, and that someone was Yeshua (Jesus). He lived a sinless life by obeying the Torah completely and after he died, he was raised to eternal life in God’s presence, which is what being saved means.

The fly in the ointment, so to speak, is that Yeshua was the only human able to live the Torah completely, all the time, so he was able to do what a human born of man and woman cannot do. God knew that, and he gave us the Torah so we would know right from wrong while at the same time provided a means of receiving forgiveness when we screwed up, which is the sacrificial system. Yeshua did not do away with that, he simply replaced the need to bring an animal to the temple to be forgiven by sacrificing himself, so that through what he did we can ask for forgiveness, even though the temple no longer exists.

Now, as for legalism before Yeshua’s time, we can go all the way back to the days of the Judges. We read how so many times people were worshipping other gods along with the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. They believed that so long as they went to services, or made the wave offerings, or sacrificed their sheep, goats, or oxen they would be OK.

The best example of this are the Samaritans, the left-overs in the Northern Kingdom after the Assyrian conquest. When Shomron (also called Israel) was defeated, Assyria disbursed most of the Jews throughout the Diaspora, leaving a remnant behind and adding to that remnant some of the peoples from other nations they had already conquered. After time, the religions of the Samaritans were bastardized collections of the different religions of the different people who lived there. That is why Samaritans were looked down upon by the Jews in the Southern Kingdom who were (supposedly) still worshipping God correctly.

When Elisha cured Naman of his Tzara’at (leprosy) in 2 Kings 5:10, Naman took some of the dirt back to his homeland so he could worship God, explaining that he will still have to worship the gods of his people when required to by his king. That is a form of legalism, thinking that by taking the dirt he is, somehow, doing what will allow him to also worship Adonai correctly.

Another example is when Nebuchadnezzar declared Adonai, the god of Daniel, the most powerful God of all (Daniel 2 and 4) he didn’t convert to Judaism. He still worshipped all his non-gods, but he acknowledged the existence and power of Adonai. He did what he thought would make him right in the eyes of the God of the Jews, but he was not faithful or obedient; he was trying to cover his tuchas, that’s all, and that is (essentially) what legalism is.

Later when Cyrus allowed the Jews to go back to Israel, ending the exile, he was doing what he thought would get in in good with their God, even to the point of providing supplies and funding the rebuilding of the temple… Legalism at its best, doing what will earn favor instead of doing from faithful trust and love.

We also can look to Constantine, who never truly converted (from what I have read), but simply legalized Christianity, adding it to his list of gods and religions he already followed. He might have done what Christians did, but if so, I am pretty sure (and yes, I am speculating) he only did it to be correct, not out of any real love or devotion to the one, true God.

Today there are still many in both Judaism and Christianity who believe doing what you should is what saves you, faithfully obeying their religion and as such, misplacing their devotion to worship and obey man-made traditions and tenets instead of trying to do what pleases God.

And I will help anyone who wants to know how to please God with this simple plan of action: do what he says, which is only found in one place, and that place is the Torah.

But don’t do it because you have to! If you don’t want to do as God says out of love for God and desire to please him, then don’t bother.

Think of obedience to the Torah not as a means of being righteous, but as a demonstration of your love and respect for God- if it isn’t a labor of love it will be impotent.

Why impotent? Because (as I’ve already pointed out) no human being can be 100% obedient to the Torah 100% of the time.

Finally, we need to realize that legalism not only existed way before Shaul, but it still exists today. Halacha (The Way to Walk) is a rabbinical collection of what to do to be correct in God’s eyes, and the “church” has so many different traditions and holidays and ways of worshipping that you MUST do (or you go to hell!) that faithfulness to God is replaced by faithfulness to a religion!

As I have said many times before, and will continue to say… GOD HAS NO RELIGION!

God has given the world his instructions for how to worship him and how to treat each other through his chosen priests, that’s us Jews (Exodus 19:6). Those aren’t just rules; they are a lifestyle and when we do what God says because we want to please him.

If you are the kind of person who is willing to do anything to please those you love here on earth, and that is the same reason you want to obey God, then you will never be legalistic.

I truly believe God isn’t as concerned with what you do as he is with why you do it.

Thank you for being here and please remember to share these messages with everyone you know, even non-believers. Hey, after all, you never know how fertile the soil is until you plant a seed in it.

That’s it for today, so L’hitraot and Baruch HaShem!